Don't Bet Your Chips on Intel, Micron
Late Thursday Micron reported an unexpected loss. In its report, Micron posted a $135 million loss of 14 cents a share for its fiscal fourth quarter. FactSet-polled analysts expected a penny a share of profit. Micron's 14% revenue drop to $2.14 billion from was slightly better than the expected $2.11 billion
The report is a mixture of bad news and good news. The bad news is that the revenues dropped due to Micron's dependence on DRAM -- where prices are dropping along with demand for PCs. The good news is that Micron has shifted its business mix in favor of the more profitable flash memory chips -- 41% of total sales. Its DRAM business is down to 36% of the total.
That's not to say that all bets on PC chips are off. Despite slowing PC sales, corporate PC demand has been stronger than many expected. And with its new PC Central Processing Unit (CPU) chip architecture -- dubbed Sandy Bridge. Intel's architecture combines "high-level graphics and CPUs integrated onto the same piece of silicon," according to eWeek.
That architecture has given Intel a phenomenal market share of 81.8% in the global processor market according to market research firm IHS iSuppli. And while the PC DRAM business features dropping prices, the CPU market remains a profit machine for the market king, Intel.
Despite slowing PC sales, corporate demand remains strong while consumer demand wanes. According to Matthew Wilkins, principal analyst for computer platforms research at IHS iSuppli, “Intel in the second quarter benefited from the combination of a recovery in PC demand and strong shipment growth for its new Sandy Bridge line of microprocessors. Strong corporate PC sales were particularly beneficial to Intel, as the enterprise computing segment has been outperforming the consumer market.”
Does this mean you should avoid Micron and buy Intel? I would avoid both but for different reasons:
- Micron: hard to predict earnings. Micron's latest report is a reversal after very strong 12 month results. During the previous 12 months, Micron revenues soared 77% to $9.1 billion while net income of $644 million was up 198% -- yielding a modest 7.1% profit margin. The stock is very cheap -- based on a Price-earnings-to-Growth ratio of 0.15 (1.0 is fair value). Micron's P/E is 8.9 on earnings forecast to grow at 58% to $0.88 in fiscal 2013. The problem for this stock is that the latest quarterly report is so much worse than expected that it throws into question the sustainability of its longer-term performance and the reliability of its forecasts.
- Intel: profitable, growing, expensive stock. Intel revenues are up 24% in the last year to $48 billion during which it posted a $12.3 billion profit, up 162% -- a whopping 25.6% net margin. The stock is expensive -- based on a Price-earnings-to-Growth ratio of 2.50. Intel's P/E is 10 on earnings forecast to grow at 4% to $2.45 in 2012. In its second quarter, Intel profit gained a mere 2% to $2.95 billion so despite its longer-term profit growth trends, its most recent results suggest that it may not be able to accelerate earnings growth.