Walgreen Can Cure What Ails Your Portfolio, CVS Not As Much
In 2006, CVS merged with Caremark, a PBM, in a $26.5 billion deal that finally closed in 2007. The idea was to create a $75 billion drug distributor whose greater scale would enable it to negotiate bigger volume discounts with the pharmaceutical companies. This deal was intended to lower corporate health care costs while achieving cost savings to help pay back the price premium.
Meanwhile, Walgreen has stuck closer to its knitting. In 2010, it spent $1.1 billion to expand its presence in New York City by acquiring Duane Reade. The deal more than doubled the number of pharmacies that Walgreen operates in the city.
Meanwhile, both CVS and Walgreens began in-store health clinics staffed by nurse practitioners in 2009. These clinics allow patients to obtain care for relatively minor health problems without an appointment. And after they are treated, they can buy their prescriptions in the stores.
But do these trends make CVS and Walgreens attractive investments? Here's my take:
- Walgreen: profitable, growing, cheap stock. Walgreen revenues are up 6.4% in the last year to $71 billion during which it posted a $2.4 billion profit, up 4.2%. the stock is fairly priced -- based on a Price-earnings-to-Growth ratio of 1.02 (1.0 is fair value). Walgreen's P/E is 13.2 on earnings forecast to grow at 12.9% to $2.96 in fiscal 2012. Tuesday, Walgreen reported a 69% pop in net income but also terminated a $5.3 billion deal with Express Scripts (NYSE: ESRX) because Walgreen felt it was not getting paid enough to fill its prescriptions.
- CVS: profitable, fairly priced stock. CVS revenues fell 2.3% to $101 billion in the last year and its net income of $3.4 billion was down 7.4%. Although it has a slim profit margin, the stock is fairly priced -- based on a Price-earnings-to-Growth ratio of 0.98 (1.0 is fair value). CVS's P/E is 14 on earnings forecast to grow at 14.3% to $3.18 in fiscal 2012. CVS's second quarter adjusted earnings of 65 cents beat expectations by a penny and were the same as the previous year.Thanks to contract wins in its PBM sector, its revenues there were up 23.2% but its margins remain tight.
I like Walgreen better than CVS because of its more rapid revenue and profit growth and its reasonable valuation.